Judge stops Justice Department from freezing 20,000 California votes
A federal court rejected an emergency request to hold ballots for voters the DOJ labels as likely noncitizens, citing the risk of disenfranchising eligible residents days before the midterms.
By Jonathan Fedorov ·

U.S. District Judge David Carter denied an emergency request from the Department of Justice to stop processing 20,000 ballots in California. The ruling, issued Wednesday evening, blocks the federal government from segregating votes tied to individuals it suspects of being noncitizens. The decision comes with only a few days remaining before the midterm election.
The Justice Department filed its lawsuit on October 15. It argued that state and local election officials must halt the processing of specific mail ballots. The DOJ claims these ballots belong to people who are "likely" not U.S. citizens. Federal prosecutors stated that once signatures on returned envelopes are verified, the ballots are separated for confidentiality. This makes it impossible to retrieve an ineligible ballot later. The department argued that votes by noncitizens dilute the impact of valid citizen votes.
California officials challenged the reliability of the federal list. A preliminary analysis by Los Angeles County found that many people on the DOJ list do not have active voter registrations. State Attorney General Rob Bonta told the court that the federal government was attempting to coerce state procedures. Bonta, a Democrat, described the litigation as a precursor to further interference. He warned that the court should not be drawn into a chilling degradation of democratic values.
Judge Carter, an appointee of former President Bill Clinton, issued a 26-page order rejecting the temporary restraining order. He noted that the federal government had never before sought to force a state to abandon its constitutional election procedures on the eve of an election. Carter expressed concern that segregating votes so close to Election Day would create chaos. He wrote that once a vote is segregated, lasting harm has occurred. The judge stated that if the Executive Branch can discount votes based on unproven allegations, the democracy is in danger.
The judge suggested the federal government address the issue through criminal indictments. DOJ officials said they have charged dozens of people in the last two months for registering or voting without citizenship. Carter indicated that this criminal path allows the government to handle the issue without disrupting the ongoing count. He declined to let the court become a party to a process that threatened the integrity of the immediate election.
The dispute over the accuracy of the list remains a central point of contention. U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services senior official Nicolas Bartell contested findings in recent court filings. Bartell wrote that his office reviewed a sample of individuals and found none were U.S.-born. However, he acknowledged that four of those people might have a claim to citizenship. Los Angeles County records, however, showed that a large portion of that sample stated they were born in the United States.
Kassra Oskooi, a political scientist at the University of Delaware, provided an expert declaration to the court. Oskooi, tapped by voting rights groups intervening in the case, stated that the USCIS matching protocol is likely unreliable. His assessment supports the state's argument that the list contains errors that could lead to the rejection of valid votes.
The Justice Department's actions in California are part of a wider series of legal moves in other states. On Monday, federal prosecutors asked Washington state officials to review a list of 400 registered voters. The DOJ also filed a lawsuit in Alaska seeking to stop the state from certifying Senate race results if the Republican incumbent loses to a longshot candidate with a similar name. These cases have raised alarms about federal interference in state election procedures near Election Day.
The Department of Justice is expected to appeal Carter's denial. The case could eventually reach the U.S. Supreme Court. For now, California election officials will continue processing the 20,000 ballots in question alongside the rest of the vote count.






