AdvertiseDonate
News you can follow.
Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Public Newz Now · 555 SE MLK Boulevard, Suite 105, Portland, OR 97214
Politics · San Diego

Federal court keeps 20,000 California ballots in count

A Ninth Circuit panel rejected the Trump administration's bid to remove votes from non-citizens, citing a lack of credible evidence.

By Jonathan Fedorov ·

Illustration for: Federal court keeps 20,000 California ballots in count
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

California voters can keep their ballots in the official count after a federal appeals court rejected the Trump administration's latest attempt to separate votes from more than 20,000 people suspected of not being U.S. citizens. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled on Friday that the government failed to prove that such a drastic measure was legally necessary during an active election.

The three-judge panel voted two to one to deny the request. The majority opinion stated that the district court correctly found no viable way to identify and remove specific ballots without causing potentially catastrophic effects on the entire election system. Judge Mark Bennet, who was appointed by President Trump, joined Judge Gabriel Sánchez, who was appointed by President Biden, in the majority decision.

Judge Patrick Bumatay, also appointed by Trump, dissented. He argued that the government's proposal was a moderate corrective measure and that the federal government and states could collaborate to protect California's long-standing rule that only citizens can vote. Bumatay wrote that the court should have allowed the government to attempt its plan.

This is the second time in one week that the appeals court has blocked the administration's intervention in the case. In early October, the Justice Department filed a lawsuit demanding that California officials set aside over 20,000 ballots. District Judge David Carter rejected that initial request on Wednesday, ruling that it violated constitutional principles that give states control over their own electoral processes.

Carter questioned the reliability of the government's methodology for creating its list of names. He noted that the Department of Homeland Security had previously estimated that up to 200,000 non-citizens were registered to vote in California, a figure far higher than the 20,000 targeted in the lawsuit. Carter also pointed to a similar case in Nevada, where the government initially claimed 15,903 non-citizens were registered, a number that eventually dropped to 185 after manual reviews, with state authorities confirming all 185 were citizens.

Kristen Clarke, the general counsel for the NAACP, which participated in the defense, said the Justice Department tried to override the voices of thousands of Californians without credible evidence. She stated that the decision confirms that elections must be governed by facts and constitutional principles rather than political interference. The Justice Department did not immediately respond to requests for comment on whether it plans to seek emergency review by the Supreme Court.

More Politics · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Public Newz Now in your inboxNews you can follow. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Latest stories

  1. CJNG Executive Sentenced To 22 Years
  2. 8,000 Flights Delayed as FAA Blames 1980s Infrastructure for Nationwide Ground Stop
  3. Commanders beat Giants to stay alive in playoff race
  4. TwitchCon pumps 60 million into San Diego
  5. 1 Joint Service Medal honors sentry who scolded Hegseth at Arlington
Get Public Newz Now in your inboxNews you can follow. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.