Solicitor General Sauer Urges Supreme Court to Halt Counting of 20,000 California Ballots
The emergency appeal seeks to segregate mail votes from individuals the federal government flagged as potential non-citizens ahead of Tuesday's midterm election.
By Jonathan Fedorov ·

Solicitor General D. John Sauer filed an emergency appeal with the Supreme Court on Monday, requesting an injunction to separate 20,000 mail ballots in California. The administration argues that the ballots belong to individuals who may not be U.S. citizens. Sauer asked the Court to direct California to stop mixing these suspected ballots with verified legal votes while the federal government pursues its case.
The appeal landed with Justice Elena Kagan, who will determine if the request qualifies as an emergency. She could request a response from California, a process that typically takes several days. The request comes one day before the midterm election. As of Sunday, California Secretary of State Shirley Weber’s office reported that more than 6.4 million ballots had already been cast. State law allows these ballots to be counted immediately.
The federal government has faced resistance in lower courts. A federal judge in Los Angeles and the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco have both rejected the administration’s previous arguments. The 9th Circuit ruled that the administration’s complaint arrived too late to impact the current election and that the legal theory regarding the Constitution was incorrect.
The dispute stems from a lawsuit filed in mid-October. The Trump administration sought to force California and Los Angeles County to set aside ballots from about 20,000 voters identified by federal authorities. Officials gave Weber and Los Angeles County Registrar-Recorder/County Clerk Dean Logan a 48-hour deadline to begin cooperating with this request. The administration compiled the list using voter data purchased from California and information from commercial platforms.
State officials and analysts from the UCLA Voting Rights Project have criticized the list’s reliability. They note that it includes U.S. citizens and individuals who are not registered to vote. State attorneys argued that complying with the federal demand during an active voting period would cause widespread disruption. They warned that the process could disenfranchise legitimate voters who were incorrectly flagged.
The 9th Circuit majority opinion, written by Judges Mark J. Bennett and Gabriel P. Sanchez, cited the Elections Clause of the Constitution. They stated that states hold primary authority over election mechanics unless Congress acts to change them. The judges noted that if the United States wants different procedures for mail ballots, it should propose legislation to Congress rather than seeking court intervention.
In dissent, Judge Patrick J. Bumatay described the administration’s request as a reasonable and modest remedy. The majority opinion referenced a 2013 case involving Arizona, where a 7-2 Supreme Court majority ruled that states could not require documentary proof of citizenship beyond the federal National Voter Registration Act. That 1993 law allows voters to register by attesting under oath that they are citizens. California follows this same standard under state law.






