California voters block billionaire wealth tax, lock in new tax limits
Proposition 40 trails by five points while a measure to constitutionally ban wealth taxes gains support.
By Tunde Martin ·

California voters rejected a proposal to tax the assets of billionaires.
As of Wednesday, Proposition 40 was trailing by approximately five percentage points. The measure would have imposed a one-time 5% tax on the wealth of California billionaires. The Service Employees International Union-United Healthcare Workers West placed the proposal on the ballot to fund medical services facing federal and state budget cuts. The union estimated the tax could raise up to $100 billion.
The campaign for the measure faced intense opposition. Billionaires targeted by the tax spent several hundred million dollars on media ads against it. The proposal also split the Democratic Party and the labor community. Many unions opposed it because the revenue would have gone exclusively to healthcare rather than shared services like education. Dave Regan, the union leader, stated that his group plans to try again if the Legislature does not provide a real solution to healthcare funding.
Voters also rejected Proposition 44 by a large margin. That measure would have required clinics serving low-income patients to spend 90% of their annual revenue directly on patient care. The defeat marks a double loss for Regan, who led the campaigns for both measures. The opposition to wealth taxes gained further ground with the likely approval of Proposition 42.
Proposition 42 places a prohibition on taxing personal wealth into the state constitution. This measure was placed on the ballot by wealthy opponents of Proposition 40 to counter the wealth tax. It partially offsets the rejection of Proposition 43, which sought to make local government taxes harder to pass. Conversely, voters appeared to approve Proposition 3. That measure makes a temporary income tax hike on high-earning Californians, first approved in 2012, permanent.
The initiative process in California has produced few long-term laws. Since 1911, 2,194 measures have been allowed to circulate petitions. Only 410 qualified for the ballot, and just 141 became law before this election. Despite the low success rate, the threat of ballot measures often forces the Legislature to act. Proposition 13, which limited property taxes in 1978, remains the most famous example of this power. Tuesday's results continue a long history of conflicts between pro-tax and anti-tax groups in the state.
The outcome positions the anti-tax faction as the victor in this cycle. Had Proposition 40 passed, it would have mirrored the national impact of the 1978 property tax limit. The failure of the wealth tax aligns with pre-election polls that showed the measure dropping into negative territory earlier in the year. The final tally will determine the exact margin of defeat, but the current count shows a consistent gap.






