Senate GOP weighs Thune re-election after midterm defeat
South Dakota senator faces internal debate over whether to remain party leader despite widespread support and no clear rival.
By Idris Romero ·

Senate Republicans gathered in a closed-door session in Washington on Tuesday to determine whether John Thune of South Dakota will remain their leader. The meeting followed steep losses in the midterm elections that stripped the party of its majority in the chamber. Senators spent two hours discussing their future before breaking without a final decision, with plans to reconvene in the afternoon.
Thune is expected to win a secret ballot vote because he remains popular among colleagues and has not faced an opponent. However, the group left the room without resolving how to proceed after losing at least seven seats. West Virginia senator Jim Justice told reporters that the party wants to be thoughtful. He noted that while no obvious alternative has emerged, there is a legitimate argument that such a heavy loss warrants new leadership.
Justice added that the current leadership did not cause the election problem and performs its duties well. The party is still processing the results of the vote. Two races in Alaska and Mississippi remain uncalled, which could further reduce Republican numbers. Several senators have asked leadership to delay the election process to allow more time for discussion.
Missouri senator Josh Hawley said he is unaware of anyone else running for the top spot but suggested that waiting might change the dynamic. Hawley criticized the idea of rushing to ratify the same leadership after such a loss. He asked what message that sends to the public if the party does not change course. Thune, who took over from Mitch McConnell in early 2025, said before the meeting that the group would have a thorough conversation to reach a consensus.
Senators emerging from the room said Thune has been listening to colleagues’ concerns rather than making his case. The discussion was described as frank and honest, with members sharing details about their own races. Wisconsin senator Ron Johnson had circulated a letter requesting a delay, arguing the conference needs soul-searching. He joked that the lack of other candidates is part of the problem, asking a reporter if they wanted the job.
Oklahoma senator Jim Lankford stated there is widespread support for Thune. He noted that Thune listens to different viewpoints before making major decisions, a style that differs from his predecessor. Lankford supported holding the elections Tuesday because many new senators are already in town for orientation. He described the leadership role as complicated and noted that few want the position.
Thune has spent the last two years managing relations with President Donald Trump. He supported most of the president’s policies but refused to scrap the filibuster to pass voting legislation requiring proof of citizenship. Trump hosted Thune at the White House in October and called him a very fine man. Thune is expected to emphasize his collaborative approach and the legislative wins of the past year when he speaks. Democrats are also holding private discussions about whether Chuck Schumer should remain their leader.






