Israel's Orthodox parties reject Netanyahu after failed conscription bill
United Torah Judaism broke with the prime minister after failing to protect yeshiva students from military service, a move that triggered leadership changes and the rise of a new political rival.
By Tunde Martin ·

United Torah Judaism, the main ultra-Orthodox Jewish party in Israel, decided not to recommend Benjamin Netanyahu to form the next government. This decision breaks a long-standing alliance between the Haredi bloc and the prime minister. The move follows the failure to pass legislation exempting yeshiva students from military service. This legislative failure exposed a fracture in the traditional political model that has dominated Israeli politics for decades.
The party's leadership recently removed Moshe Gafni from its head of party position. Gafni served in the Knesset since 1988 and was one of the most influential figures in Haredi politics. The official reason for his removal was a need to refresh the leadership. However, the decision also reflected the political costs of failing to secure legal status for full-time Torah scholars. Yaakov Asher, a Knesset member since 2013 and former mayor of Bnei Brak, replaced Gafni as the alliance chair.
Asher is viewed as loyal to Rabbi Dov Landau, the leader of the Lithuanian Haredi community. Landau and his inner circle sought tighter control over parliamentary representatives. Asher stated in a recent interview that he represents both full-time scholars and working Haredim. This message targets younger voters who are increasingly active in the economy. Despite this outreach, Asher remains firm on the issue of conscription, having resigned as Interior Committee chairman in protest over the lack of regulation for yeshiva students.
A new party, HaTzibur HaHaredi, has entered the political scene to challenge the established parties. The group won a small number of votes but represents a shift in the Haredi voting behavior. It appeals to members of the community who feel isolated from the wider state. Dr. Nechumi Yaffe, a scholar of Haredi society, joined the party as a candidate. This move signals an effort to broaden representation beyond the traditional male-dominated political establishment.
The Sephardi Haredi party Shas faced its own crisis after dropping from 11 seats in 2022 to six in the latest election. The party lost nearly 100,000 votes in the process. Longtime leader Aryeh Deri resigned but was rejected by the party's Council of Torah Sages. He kept his position as party chairman but gave up his Knesset seat. Shas was founded as a social movement for traditional Jews who felt excluded from power centers in Israel.
Both United Torah Judaism and Shas now court different political partners. United Torah Judaism abstained during consultations with President Isaac Herzog, leaving the door open for both Netanyahu and Gadi Eisenkot. Eisenkot has one month to form a government. The Haredi parties are positioning themselves as potential partners for either camp. This strategic ambiguity reflects a community that is redefining its relationship with the state and its internal leadership structures.






