Santa Ana Mayor: First-time attorney wins city hall
Dan Shimell defeated incumbent Valerie Amezcua in a race defined by immigration policy and police accountability.
By Jonathan Fedorov ·

Dan Shimell is set to become the next mayor of Santa Ana, ending the tenure of Valerie Amezcua. Shimell, a 40-year-old attorney and first-time candidate, secured the lead after a four-day period of counting votes. He had trailed Amezcua by 13% of the vote on initial Election Night results before taking the lead on Saturday and widening it through Tuesday.
Amezcua, the city's first elected Latina mayor, conceded shortly after the Monday result update. At the time of her concession, about 77% of Santa Ana's residents identified as Latino. Shimell received no advertising spending from outside groups, while Amezcua received over $110,000 from the local police union to support her campaign.
Shimell attributed his victory to resident frustration over immigration enforcement and police conduct. He noted that the city's population has felt treated as if on probation for years. He stated that this frustration created a hunger for new leadership. By Tuesday evening's 5 p.m. update, Shimell held about 47% of the vote, leading Amezcua by more than 4,200 votes.
Amezcua had the endorsement of the Orange County Democratic Party and several labor and public safety unions. She referred to herself as the people's mayor. However, she faced criticism for her response to 2025 immigration raids. She called subsequent protests pure violence and destruction of property. Many residents and council members cited this statement as a key reason for her defeat.
Shimell moved to Santa Ana in 2020 during the pandemic. He previously lived in Costa Mesa and Tustin. He said he became involved in local politics after witnessing the city's response to ICE raids. He decided to run for mayor in May and June of this year after finding few other challengers. His campaign relied on family and volunteers, including his wife and father-in-law, who canvassed during lunch breaks.
Campaign filings show Shimell paid Epic Strategies Group about $2,000 for consulting services. He received a $1,000 refund from the firm in October. He primarily funded his campaign through personal loans. Ray Diaz, an Orange County Parks Commissioner and volunteer, said Shimell won because residents wanted a change in approach to immigration and public safety.
Shimell is not the only newcomer gaining ground in Santa Ana elections. Three progressive-backed candidates are leading their police union-backed opponents in other city council races. This includes the Ward 4 race against incumbent Phil Bacerra and the Ward 6 race against Giovanni Chavez. Councilman Ben Vazquez, who lost to Amezcua in 2024, said Shimell's likability and forum performances gave residents hope.
Shimell said he plans to address the city's relationship with ICE immediately. He wants to fast-track the investigation into the arrest of resident Florentino Lopez and make the findings public. He also intends to remove Flock cameras. He disagrees with the previous administration's low-profile approach to immigration in a sanctuary city. He stated the city must protect its residents even if it draws attention.
Sandra De Anda, an immigrant rights advocate, said Shimell's values aligned with resident desires for change. She noted he met with people throughout the city and spoke up about ICE. Isuri Ramos, a Chispa executive director, said Shimell showed sincerity by asking council to protect neighbors from ICE last summer. These endorsements reflect the wave of progressive candidates challenging established political figures in the city.






