Montana Democrats split over Bodnar loss
Party leaders blame a divided ticket for the Senate defeat, while experts argue the independent candidate outperformed the party brand in rural areas.
By Idris Romero ·

Montana Democrats are debating whether their 2026 Senate defeat resulted from a split vote between the party nominee and an independent challenger. State Director Emily Marburger said Wednesday that the national trend of independent candidates failed to deliver results in Montana. She argued that Seth Bodnar should have run under the Democratic banner to capture the full wave of progressive voters.
"Really, what I’m looking at now is Seth Bodnar should have run as a Democrat if he wanted to run," Marburger said. "He should have looked at the playing field. What ended up happening was a split ticket."
The math behind this claim is disputed. As of Wednesday afternoon, with 92% of ballots counted, Bodnar had 171,327 votes, or 37%. Democratic nominee Alani Bankhead received 54,982 votes. Together, they collected 226,309 votes. This total exceeded the 223,427 votes won by Republican victor Kurt Alme, who received 49% of the vote. Libertarians captured 2% of the electorate.
Kevin Smith, a political scientist at the University of Nebraska, cautioned against simple addition. He noted that the Democratic brand remains unpopular with some voters who supported Bodnar. "I get where this comes from, add Bankhead’s 12% to Bodnar’s 37% and it’s game on, right?" Smith said. "The issue I see here is that I suspect Montana is similar to Nebraska in the sense that the Democratic Party brand is still seen very negatively by some of those voting for the independent."
Jeremy Johnson, head of political science at Carroll College in Helena, pointed to county returns showing Bodnar outperforming Democrats in rural districts. "Even in the most Republican counties, he’s doing better than Democrats did two years ago, significantly so," Johnson said. Nonpartisan ballot measures also won strong support. Initiatives to limit corporate spending and preserve initiative power both received 65% approval. A measure to keep judicial races nonpartisan passed with 68% of the vote.
Nancy Keenan, a former party chair who endorsed Bodnar, said Democrats must form coalitions to win. She noted that Democrats represent only 19% to 22% of the electorate, while independents make up 42%. Keenan argued that the primary field lacked a viable winner. Former state legislator Reilly Neill, the most funded primary candidate, was unknown to 60% of voters. The other four candidates were unfamiliar to 70% of the public.
"I sure think it would have been closer if Bankhead were not in the race, but close enough to push Bodnar over the winner’s line? Maybe, but probably not," Smith said. Supreme Court winner Amy Eddy campaigned on her nonpartisan status, while her Republican opponent Dan Wilson emphasized his party affiliation. Keenan said the party must find new alliances to advance its values.






