Justice Department seeks contempt against CHIRLA over voter data findings
Attorneys for the immigrant rights group found that over 40% of names in a federal list of suspected noncitizen voters in California do not appear in state records.
By Jonathan Fedorov ·

The U.S. Department of Justice filed a motion on Sunday urging a federal judge to sanction the Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights, or CHIRLA, and its legal team. The government argues that the group violated a court order by publishing an analysis of a database containing more than 20,000 names of suspected noncitizen voters in California.
U.S. District Court Chief Judge James Boasberg granted CHIRLA access to this data on Friday. He based the decision on the plaintiffs' need to prove their legal standing to challenge the administration's use of the list. Boasberg instructed the plaintiffs to keep the names confidential and to use the data solely for arguments regarding their standing in the case.
On Saturday, CHIRLA attorneys submitted court papers detailing their findings. Their analysis indicated that more than 40% of the individuals on the federal list do not appear in California’s state voter file. The group also identified 22 people who appear to be naturalized U.S. citizens, while noting that thousands of other citizens seemed to be included on the list.
In its Sunday filing, the Justice Department contended that the group's findings regarding general inaccuracies and comparisons to the full state voter file were irrelevant to the specific question of whether the named plaintiffs had standing. The department suggested that Judge Boasberg refer the matter for a criminal contempt investigation.
"The report’s political grandstanding about alleged inaccuracies that purportedly impact California voters generally, or comparisons between the government’s list and the full ‘California voter file,’ has no relevance to whether the particular plaintiffs in this case have standing," the filing stated.
Alberto Lammers, a spokesman for the UCLA Voting Rights Project which conducted the analysis for CHIRLA, responded via email. He stated that plaintiffs' counsel and their experts fully complied with the court's orders.
The Justice Department also appealed a separate ruling on Sunday. U.S. District Judge Trina L. Thompson had barred the department from demanding that election offices remove possible noncitizens from voter rolls or separate their ballots on Friday. Thompson scheduled a hearing on the appeal for Monday. California election officials have argued the list contains numerous errors and that they lack sufficient time to verify eligibility before the election.






