San Diego Police Failure Rate on Firearms Tests Doubles in 2026
Twenty-five officers failed all five qualification attempts this year, prompting calls from the police union for a new department-owned shooting range.
By Jonathan Fedorov ·

San Diego police officers failed their mandatory firearms qualification tests at nearly twice the rate of previous years, according to data reviewed by NBC 7 Investigates. The analysis of nearly 500 pages of public records shows that 25 officers failed all five permitted attempts in 2026, a sharp increase from the 13 officers who failed in 2025 and the typical annual total seen since 2018. Officers who fail all five attempts are removed from street duty and assigned to desk work while completing remedial training, a status known informally as a "five-timer."
The San Diego Police Officers Association expressed concern over the rise in failures, noting that marksmanship is the most critical skill for an officer. President Jared Wilson stated that when an officer must use a weapon, they must be aiming accurately and hitting the intended target. Wilson argued that the department's closure of its local shooting range in 2022 created barriers to consistent practice. He described shooting as a perishable skill that requires regular maintenance, which officers are currently unable to perform as often as before.
The department previously operated an outdoor range near the Mount Hope neighborhood, which was shuttered in 2022 after more than a dozen officers reported illnesses. City records revealed that an engineer recommended purchasing equipment to remove toxic lead dust during renovations, but the city declined the cost as optional. The department now leases space at a private range in Poway, a significant distance from most police stations. Under the current contract, officers must share a single lane, whereas the former city-owned facility had four.
Captain Michael Ramsay, who heads the department's Training Division, acknowledged that the failure rate is concerning but said it has not been a historical trend. He noted that the department offers approximately 60 hours of free training time monthly but must balance that availability with officer workload and command approval. Ramsay said he is exploring other range options with the chief's office to address the long-term need for more space.
Retired FBI firearms instructor Eric Robinson said that logistical hurdles often discourage officers from seeking extra practice. He noted that the hassle of coordinating time off while under supervision pressure can lead officers to skip additional drills. Robinson emphasized that proficiency comes from thoughtfully applied drills rather than just qualification courses. The current contract for the Poway range could cost taxpayers up to $4.1 million from 2022 onward.
Wilson said the department needs a permanent solution rather than a temporary fix, as the current situation has persisted for five years. The department has not provided a definitive explanation for the 2026 spike in failures, with officials stating that training methods have remained consistent.






