DOJ seeks court order to isolate Alaska ballots in Senate race probe
Federal officials confirmed a criminal investigation into a challenger who shares a name with the incumbent senator, days before the ranked choice general election.
By Tunde Martin ·

The U.S. Department of Justice requested a court order on Friday to isolate specific ballots in Alaska's Senate race while federal officials confirmed the existence of a criminal probe. The investigation centers on a candidate who shares a name with the incumbent Republican senator. This legal and investigative action occurred days before the Tuesday general election, a contest widely viewed as critical for Senate control.
Alaska U.S. Attorney Michael Heyman stated that the criminal investigation has continued for several months. He noted that recent reporting by The New York Times regarding the recruitment of retired teacher Dan J. Sullivan by the Democratic campaign led to a surge of law enforcement assets in the state. Heyman did not specify the potential crimes under review or the targets of the probe, but he asked the public to provide tips to investigators.
Separately, the Justice Department filed a lawsuit asking a judge to order state elections officials to segregate ballots ranking Dan J. Sullivan. Assistant U.S. Attorney E. Bryan Wilson wrote that the government seeks to preserve these ballots to investigate whether the rankings resulted from voter confusion. The filing argues there is a substantial risk that the candidacy misleads voters and compromises the integrity of the electoral process. The department requested a decision by Monday.
The Department of Justice also submitted a list of proposed questions it intends to compel the Peltola campaign and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee to answer. These questions are part of a civil case seeking to block the certification of the race if the incumbent loses. President Donald Trump stated that he instructed the department to file the case.
State attorneys challenged the feasibility of the segregation request. They argued that ballots are commingled in boxes on Election Day and that separating them would violate ballot secrecy protections. They noted that segregated ballots would not reveal a voter's reason for choosing Dan J. Sullivan. The state asked a judge to dismiss the case, pointing out that officials already distinguished the candidates on the ballot. The incumbent is listed as Dan S. Sullivan, while the challenger appears as Daniel J. Sullivan Jr.
State attorneys also contended that Alaska's ranked voting system mitigates confusion by allowing voters to rank both candidates. They highlighted that the same naming convention was used on the August open primary ballot. The state emphasized that their efforts to distinguish the two Sullivans on the ballot were sufficient.
Democratic candidate Mary Peltola denied knowledge of the effort to place Dan J. Sullivan on the ballot. She stated that she is not interested in tricking voters and expressed deep offense at the accusations of involvement with another person's candidacy. Peltola said she does not need assistance outside of voter support. When asked if a campaign member might have been involved in recruiting the challenger, she told KTUU that she had no idea.
Peltola referenced Elisa Rios, a former campaign manager who was fired before the primary, saying that certain people are gone for a good reason. She added that if she could fire them again, she would be happy to do so. The New York Times report on the recruitment was partly based on interviews with Rios. Federal prosecutors issued dozens of grand jury subpoenas and record preservation requests this week, according to a person familiar with the matter.
Alaska Governor Mike Dunleavy ordered an investigation into potential violations following the New York Times reporting. In a separate legal matter, the Alaska Democratic Party sued state elections officials over absentee voting sites. The Division of Elections director said in a Monday letter that most of the 18 sites highlighted in the lawsuit opened as agreed.
President Trump attended a rally in Florida late Friday and suggested that Peltola and Dan J. Sullivan should be prosecuted. He told U.S. Attorney General Todd Blanche to make his own decision regarding the case. Blanche indicated agreement with the suggestion. Peltola held a campaign rally in Anchorage late Friday, where she addressed the ongoing legal and investigative developments.






