AdvertiseDonate
News you can follow.
Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Public Newz Now · 555 SE MLK Boulevard, Suite 105, Portland, OR 97214
News · National

Art Experts Advise Buying Local, Not Auctions

New data suggests art underperformed stocks over the last decade, prompting specialists to urge new buyers to focus on culture over capital gains.

By Idris Romero ·

Illustration for: Art Experts Advise Buying Local, Not Auctions
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

A recent analysis of ten-year annualized returns through 2024 reveals that the stock market vastly outperformed the art sector. During this period, art produced some of its worst returns in seven decades, despite a strong bull market in equities. As of 2026, younger buyers are entering the market in greater numbers, yet experts caution that the sector remains the least transparent investment environment imaginable.

The opacity of the art market creates a distinct disadvantage for new entrants. Canice Prendergast, an economics professor at the University of Chicago, noted that insiders often know who has purchased specific artists or who will secure museum shows years in advance. "What I tell people is that there is so much inside information in the art world.. that if you are an outsider, you have little hope" of catching the next big wave early, Prendergast said. He oversees the Chicago Booth School of Business Harper Center's contemporary art collection, which houses more than 650 artworks.

Magnus Resch, an art economics professor at Yale University, emphasized that most art is not a good investment. For buyers operating on limited budgets, he stated they are unlikely to see a financial return. He advised new collectors to buy art they love from local galleries, artists discovered on Instagram, or direct exhibitions at art fairs. "Assume you'll never see your money again," Resch said. "You're not investing for financial returns. You're investing in yourself, the artist, and the gallery."

Understanding the market structure is essential for those who do choose to buy. Prendergast explained that the primary market consists of galleries, while the secondary market involves auctions. Significant value increases typically occur as art moves from lower-tier galleries to mid-tier ones and finally to auction. He cited Louis Fratino as an example. Fratino’s work moved from mid-tier gallery David Fierman in New York City to mega-gallery David Zwirner. That jump resulted in a 20x increase in the price of his paintings. Such moves are rare and difficult to predict, often taking years to unfold.

Roman Kräussl, a finance professor at the Bayes Business School in London, said art provides a lower risk-adjusted return than financial markets. However, it can serve as a hedge against financial market risk. He noted that costs such as buyer’s premiums, shipping, insurance, framing, storage, and resale fees factor into the overall return. Kräussl argued that the greater opportunity in art lies in engaging with culture rather than beating the market. "You will meet the most interesting people of your life," he said. "Do not 'Spotify' art. Go to small events. See the artists. Experience."

For specific budgets, Resch recommended different strategies. At $5,000, he suggested looking for prints or works on paper by blue-chip artists, ideally at auction. At $10,000, original works in contemporary art day sales at major auction houses are an option. At $100,000, the focus can shift to artists represented by leading galleries who have exhibited at major museums. "I'd rather buy one exceptional work for $100,000 than five mediocre ones for $20,000 each," Resch said.

Georgina Adam, editor at large for The Art Newspaper, advised buyers to study the artist before purchasing. She cautioned against buying on a whim and recommended seeking dealers with a proven track record and membership in professional associations. Adam specifically warned against buying art from eBay, noting that fakes can be accompanied by fake certificates of authenticity. "Fairs enable the buyer to look around in a less pressured environment and get prices," she said.

The 2026 Art Basel and UBS Survey of Global Collecting found that painting remains the most popular medium for high-net-worth collectors. It accounted for 76% of buyer participation and 31% of total fine art expenditure. Sculpture followed with 15% of spending, works on paper with 10%, and digital art with 9%. Most collectors in the survey reported conducting their own research before making a purchase.

More News · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Public Newz Now in your inboxNews you can follow. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Latest stories

  1. CJNG Executive Sentenced To 22 Years
  2. 8,000 Flights Delayed as FAA Blames 1980s Infrastructure for Nationwide Ground Stop
  3. Commanders beat Giants to stay alive in playoff race
  4. TwitchCon pumps 60 million into San Diego
  5. 1 Joint Service Medal honors sentry who scolded Hegseth at Arlington
Get Public Newz Now in your inboxNews you can follow. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.