Orange County D.A. Todd Spitzer to File Court Motion Against Newsom's Death Row Commutations
The district attorney plans to challenge the governor's blanket sentence reduction before the state Supreme Court on Monday, citing voter mandates and due process concerns.
By Jonathan Fedorov ·

Orange County District Attorney Todd Spitzer will file a motion with the California Supreme Court on Monday to challenge Governor Gavin Newsom’s decision to commute death sentences. The legal action targets the governor’s move to convert all remaining death row sentences to life in prison without the possibility of parole.
Spitzer announced the plan at a news conference held with relatives of murder victims. He stated that the office intends to push back against what he described as an override of the will of voters. Spitzer noted that voters supported the death penalty a decade ago and also approved a proposition to expedite the review process.
“The reason the governor feels he can get away with this is because he doesn’t believe there are any consequences,” Spitzer said. He argued that the state’s highest court should reject any change in sentencings it has previously upheld. “Doesn’t this go against everything the Supreme Court stands for?” he asked.
The district attorney acknowledged the legal hurdle is steep. “I think we may have to get down on our knees in this one,” Spitzer told the prosecutors and crime victim advocates present. He asked the group to pray for the effort.
Spitzer accused the governor of using the issue for political gain. He claimed Newsom was moving left to secure the presidential nomination. The D.A. expressed offense that the governor commuted the terms for all 548 inmates at once rather than reviewing each case individually.
He argued that the inmates will eventually get chances at parole despite the new sentence structure. To his critics, Spitzer said, “Shame on you. Go to hell. … You’re going to attack (crime victims)?” He recalled witnessing the 2006 execution of Clarence Ray Allen, the last prisoner put to death in the state.
Steve Herr, father of Sam Herr, shared the family’s perspective at the event. Sam Herr was killed by condemned inmate Daniel Wozniak in Costa Mesa. Herr described how investigators found his son’s head on what would have been his 27th birthday. He criticized the governor for not meeting with victims’ families before making the decision.
Herr noted that Wozniak gained computer access, took classes, and had more social freedom while on death row. “How does he do this without addressing the families face to face?” Herr said. “He did it while in his office. … That was a cowardly act. … Daniel Wozniak broke my heart. Gavin Newsom broke my soul.”






